If there is one thing you can count on in the financial press, it’s that there is always some looming “crisis.” So far in 2026, they have included multiple credit crises (private credit, U.S. Treasuries, sovereign bonds in general) along with a crisis in energy, stock market valuations, inflation, and, of course, AI. A mid-September article on MSN.com from The Telegraph provides the archetype for this kind of reporting: “The four horsemen of the apocalypse are coming for the global economy.” Apparently, “Four powerful shocks are hitting the world economy at the same time. They are escalating and feeding on each other, driving a commodity spiral that can end only in an inflationary blow-off.”
These scare-for-clicks tactics can create an irrational fear of a terrible crisis looming just over the horizon. And yet, fear isn’t necessarily irrational. Financial crises do happen. This article provides a framework for dealing with that paradox: how to think about financial crises and what you should, and more importantly, should not, do about them today.
Is Moving to Safety Really Safer?
A common response to fear is a flight to safety, which typically means investors selling their risky investments and buying gold or stable investments like Treasury Bills. Let’s look at those responses through a historical lens.
Moving to gold.
People imagine gold is a safe alternative to the stock market. Yet earlier this year, the price of gold fell by more than 25% in less than four months. Gold isn’t a panacea against large, sudden losses. Gold rarely stumbles this much, but that’s true for all standard asset classes. The last time the stock market fell more than 25% in less than four months was the 2020 COVID crisis. Before that, it had been over 30 years since that kind of rapid (>25% drop in less than four months) stock market tumble: the crash of 1987, often called Black Monday. Gold, on the other hand, has experienced three sharp drops this century, in 2008 and 2013 as well as this year. And, of course, the mother of all gold corrections was in early 1980, with the price falling over 40% in less than two months.
Worse, gold doesn’t offer the long-term returns available in the stock market, so it tends to take longer to recover from a drop. Over the past 50 years, the S&P 500 earned a compound total annual return of 11.9% while gold returned 7.1%. The difference is massive over decades: $1,000 invested in stocks for those 50 years would have grown to almost $280,000, compared with $31,000 if invested in gold.
And gold doesn’t tend to recover quickly. Its 18-month recovery from 2008 lows may have been its fastest. It took seven years for gold prices to return to their 2013 peak and 28 years to recover from the 1980 crash. In contrast, the stock market recovered from its COVID drop over the next five months and its 1987 crash in 20 months. History suggests gold has similar downside to stocks but without the higher returns that enable rapid rebounds.
Of course, there are shorter periods in which gold outperforms stocks, specifically windows that span the 2000/01 tech bust and the 2008-09 financial crisis or include the recent 175% spike in gold prices between early 2024 and early 2026. The point isn’t that stocks always beat gold; it’s that stocks beat gold 70% of the time with similar downside risk.
Moving to cash.
This means investing in very stable assets like Treasury Bills, accepting low but certain returns.
Going to cash before a crisis avoids the associated market drop, but what if the crisis never comes? And even if it does come, what about after? Being in cash in early 2020 avoided the S&P 500’s -33.8% return between February 19th and March 23rd, and missed the astonishing 108% rebound over the next two years. Starting from the February 19th peak to capture both the crash and rebound, the S&P 500 returned 32.6% over two years (2/19/20-2/18/2022), a 15.1% annual return. Cash, on the other hand, earned a safe annual return well below 1%.
And even that safe return isn’t as safe as it first appears. T-Bill investors didn’t lose money, but they lost roughly 10% of their purchasing power when their returns lagged inflation. Gold returned roughly 18% over the same period, more than inflation but barely half the S&P 500’s return.
History is clear: neither gold nor cash have outperformed stocks over the long run. But what about moving to gold or cash in the face of a crisis and then returning to stocks after the risks recede but before the rebound begins?
Why Timing a Financial Crisis Doesn't Work
Theoretically, this is a great strategy! So is winning the lottery! But neither can be reliably executed. The risks don’t recede before the rebound begins.
Nobody knows when a crisis will hit or how long it will last. Consider COVID: How plausible is it that an investor worried about a global pandemic enough to move their portfolio into gold or cash in early 2020 would reenter the market in the midst of a rapidly spreading global pandemic in late March? By definition, the market bottom happens when things look their absolute worst. In practice, this is when investors are the least likely to get back into the stock market. Selling at the bottom is much, much more common than reentering the market.
Knowing this, what is there to do today?
First, we can do something that the financial press rarely, if ever, does: distinguish what we mean by a crisis. We like a framework based on four increasing levels: a false crisis, a real crisis, a financial meltdown, and an apocalypse. Adopting this framework when things are quiet helps us make thoughtful decisions when things get messy.
There is a lot of angst in both false and real crises; the difference is what’s actually happening. A real crisis has observable market signals that are alarming – not just concerning – when taken in the proper context. Despite what the financial press would like you to believe, “Treasury yields surge to a near 20-year high…” (a recent NBC News headline) isn’t a real crisis when those 20 years are two decades of historically rock-bottom interest rates. The stock market falling 30%, on the other hand, signals a real crisis.
The difference between a crisis and a meltdown comes down to depth and breadth, as well as speed and duration. The bear market following the 1990s internet boom was deep and fast, and continued after 9/11, exacerbating the downturn. But it was relatively narrowly limited to technology stocks and later sectors like airlines. This kept it a crisis rather than a meltdown.
The COVID-19 crisis was deep, broad, and fast – but very short. Crisis, not meltdown.
The 2008-09 Great Recession began as a crisis among mortgage lenders and insurers but then spread broadly across equity and credit markets, lasting years. Being deep, broad, fast, and long constitutes a financial meltdown. The stock market fell over 50%, and credit spreads (e.g., the difference between the interest rate on AAA corporate bonds and Treasury Bonds) expanded to 2-3x their levels in the dot-com bust.
These are the hallmarks of a financial meltdown. And it is important to remember that despite the fear and pain, well-diversified portfolios survived the Great Recession and went on to thrive. An apocalypse is something our financial investments may not necessarily survive. The closest thing we have from history is the Great Depression, but even that falls short.
A financial apocalypse would be like a meteor hitting the Earth or a super-volcano eruption – something very unlikely that you can neither predict nor really plan for. And yet, that is what the financial press continually suggests. Recall that “The four horsemen of the apocalypse are coming for the global economy.”
And here’s something worth considering: If a catastrophe were severe enough to permanently destroy the global financial system, your investment portfolio would probably be the least of your concerns. Your net worth, regardless of where or how you held it, would be unlikely to survive intact either.
That’s the problem with trying to invest for the financial apocalypse. The scenarios that make for the most frightening headlines are often the very scenarios against which no investment strategy could reliably protect you.
It is irrational to let fear of a financial apocalypse drive our investment plan. Preparing for a crisis or market meltdown, however, is different. Market downturns, recessions, and financial crises are recurring features of investing. History tells us they will happen and eventually end.
So rather than trying to protect ourselves against the end of civilization, we should focus on building portfolios that can withstand the difficult periods we know we’ll encounter.
Given that, what is there to do?
How to Prepare Your Portfolio for a Financial Crisis
Diversification is a powerful tool for protecting yourself against a crisis because it is, by definition, relatively narrow. Diversification also lowers the chance that a decline becomes psychologically intolerable – one part of your portfolio may suffer, but others may hold up or even rise.
Thoughtful planning can protect you in a meltdown because it can help you avoid making mistakes at the worst possible time by making sure you have the cushion to make good decisions. Holding the right amount of cash is different from abandoning the long-term returns available in the stock market. Cash is for managing liquidity risk, not investment risk.
Virtually all investors’ portfolios decline in a meltdown. Even lower-risk assets can experience large price corrections as panic leads to indiscriminate selling.
The important question is what happens after the crisis hits. Do cash needs force you to sell at the bottom? Do you panic and sell at the bottom even though you have plenty of cash? What you need going into the crisis is a suitable portfolio and a relationship with an advisor you trust (not a media publication or journalist with very different incentives) that allows you to respond with an emphatic NO to both questions.
Selling at the bottom is the greatest risk once a downturn appears. Investors understandably fear a crisis/meltdown – there have been two in the past 20 years: the financial meltdown in 2008-09 and the COVID-19 crisis in early 2020, and in both cases the S&P 500 fell over one-third, and it looked like things might get much worse.
Further, while the market fully recovered in five months in the COVID crisis, it took three years for investors to fully recover their 2008 financial meltdown losses. A crisis is scary, but a meltdown hurts – and that pain can put investors on edge.
However, investors often forget an important lesson on the other side – not only do crises/meltdowns begin with a bang, but they also tend to end that way too. Both the 2008 and 2020 bear markets ended with the S&P 500 rebounding more than 20% in approximately two weeks. Missing that, or worse, selling at the bottom is very expensive.
Your financial plan should be designed to mitigate risk through diversification. Portfolios concentrated in technology stocks in early 2000, financial stocks in 2007, or energy and travel stocks in early 2020 suffered much larger losses when trouble hit. Your plan should also be designed to give you the financial cushion to make good decisions when everyone else is panicking. A crisis doesn’t last forever, but if you sell at the bottom, it might as well for your investment portfolio.
Build a Financial Plan Designed for Uncertain Markets
You can’t predict when the next financial crisis will happen, but you can have a plan designed to help you navigate one. At Hendershott Wealth Management®, we build diversified financial plans around your goals, liquidity needs, and long-term financial life, so short-term market uncertainty doesn’t have to dictate your decisions.
Disclaimer:
All investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. There is no guarantee that any investment plan or strategy will be successful. Advisory services provided by Hendershott Wealth Management, LLC (“HWM”), an investment advisor registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.
All written content in this piece is for information purposes only and does not constitute an offer, or solicitation of an offer, or any advice, or recommendation to purchase any securities or other financial instruments–and may not be construed as such. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of HWM, unless otherwise specifically cited. Material presented is believed to be from reliable sources and no representations are made by our firm as to another parties’ informational accuracy or completeness. All information or ideas provided should be discussed in detail with an advisor, accountant or legal counsel prior to implementation. HWM does not provide tax or legal advice.

